
If you know me, you know I love me some Lifetime/Hallmark style Christmas movies. I usually refer to these as LifeMark films. They’re easy, usually inoffensive, and full of the Christmas spirit. That being said, these aren’t limited to Lifetime or Hallmark. Every year we get more of these films coming out on streaming, straight to VOD, or sometimes even to theaters. This year brings us a new one on Hulu starring Lucy Hale and her Pretty Little Liar’s costar Ian Harding. Here’s my review of The 12 Dates of Christmas.

The 12 Dates of Christmas follows Christina Walker who’s far too busy to think about love. But one Christmas, she’s sick of her mother’s constant nagging about her being single so she promises that she won’t be without a date next Christmas. Flash forward a year and Christina only has a few weeks left to find a date. Can a new dating app help her find love? And what about her old high school crush coming back to town?
I’m far more forgiving about holiday themed movies because I feel that the point of films like these are different from your every day film. These movies are aides to help you get into the spirit of the season. They’re supposed to fill you with warmth and be so full of Christmas that you can’t help but get in the yuletide mood. So even if a movie is 100% predictable. Even if it’s full of the normally boring tropes, I’ll dive right in if it delivers on that feeling. (Needle drop: Hooked on a Feeling)
I like to break down Christmas movies into categories. Early December, Leading up to Christmas, and The Week of. This film falls directly into the “Early December” category because even though this is about the lead up to Christmas, it’s not very Christmassy. In fact, the only reason I could really tell that this was a Christmas film, besides the title, was scattered decorations and the fact that they keep counting down to the holiday. It’s far from the worst offender when it comes to a Christmas movie not having Christmas references, but I still want more Ho ho ho than humbug.

The 12 Dates of Christmas is banking on fans of Pretty Little Liars. Just like movies like The Christmas Wish bank on fans of One Tree Hill, this film brings two of your favorite actors from a popular TV show and reunites them under different circumstances. I had never seen Pretty Little Liars so I wasn’t invested in that aspect so maybe that could have affected my enjoyment.
The Strength in this film sits on the shoulders of Lucy Hale. She’s so fun and charismatic that I couldn’t help but like her character even if it felt like the story moved too fast. We needed far more of Christina and Pete (Lucy and Ian) together so we could root for them. The basis of the viewer wanting them together is just that Christina had 12 terrible dates in a row with everyone from a ventriloquist to a guy who had to run her by his mom first. She’s had so many awful dates that we can’t help but root for the handsome and kind blast from her past, right?

The 12 awful dates were fun because even though they’re so over the top, some did allude to real life issues. A person to attached to their phone, someone who is too focused on doing things their way, and the person who’s a little too close to their dog. Don’t bring your non service dog to a restaurant. Even though these dates were over-the-top with how bad they were, it was also never cruel. Lucy Hale and Ian Harding are conventionally attractive people, but when Lucy goes on a date with a bigger guy or someone who could be deemed as “funny looking” those facts never even came up.
I enjoyed this film if only because of Lucy Hale’s talent and the few times they were on screen together, she did have great chemistry with Ian Harding. While I do think the film needed some tweaking by either slowing down the pacing or by extending the run time and adding some scenes between the two leads, I can’t ignore the fact that I had fun.
Is this an every year watch? Maybe not. But in early December of next year, if my wife suggests we watch this, I would be down. The 12 Dates of Christmas has its heart in the right place, but sloppy execution keeps this from being anything more than a film to put on in the background.
The 12 Dates of Christmas gets a 6 out of 11
